Participating in Search Design: A Study of George Thomason's English Newsbooks

Summary:

Using participatory design methods to understand how search is used within humanities research in order to to improve search interfaces.

Project Status:

Completed

Funders:

Arts and Humanities Research Council (AHRC)

Partners:

University of Sheffield
Capita
ProQuest

Subjects:

digital archive, early modern period, early printed books, English studies, historical records, history, newspapers and periodocals, online resource, participatory design, transcriptions

Technologies:

CSS, HTML, Java, Lucene

Online Publication

Project Website

Project Description

This project investigates how search is used within humanities research methodology and aims to improve the design of search interfaces for online resources to meet the changing needs of research communities. Data searching is now a core activity within humanities research and, given the vast evidence base which is now available to scholars in a digital form, the design of search has a significant impact on research results. However, research communities are rarely consulted meaningfully when content providers design online resources and there tends to be an assumption that the search needs of humanities research are the same as those in other disciplines or in non-academic knowledge gathering. This project will map existing search methodologies, their benefits and limitations in order to design a user interface for a test dataset (and evaluate its impact on research in the field). The project involves collaboration between Sheffield University’s departments of History, English and Sociological Studies, the Humanities Research Institute and the digital content provider ProQuest. Our dataset is 50,000 pages of seventeenth-century newsbooks collected by the seventeenth-century bookseller George Thomason, currently only available on microfilm or as digitised images via ProQuest’s Early English Books Online (EEBO). Test research questions for addressing the potential impact of the search design will revolve around understanding the role of newsbooks as drivers of community formation; we will also explore the use of Participatory Design in developing search interfaces within the humanities. Our aim is to ensure that the design of ICT meets the needs of users by involving users in the design process and we will address five research questions:

1. What is the role of search within humanities research methodology, how is it used across the different subject domains, what are its current deficiencies and what impact does it have on research results?

2. How is the design of search conditioned by technical considerations or the viewpoint of content creators?

3. What would constitute good search design within the humanities and how would it support and transform research methodology?

4. Is it possible to design new types of search which meet the community’s differing methodological requirements more effectively than current approaches?

5. What constitutes effective development methodology in the digital humanities and electronic publishing in terms of ensuring that user requirements are constantly addressed? Does a Participatory Design approach meet these needs?

Project Team

  • Prof. Michael Braddick (Principal Investigator – University of Sheffield)
  • Dr Bridgette Wessels (Co-Investigator – University of Sheffield)
  • Dr Marcus Nevitt (Co-Investigator – University of Sheffield)
  • Dr Louise Sorensen (Research Associate – University of Sheffield)
  • Jamie McLaughlin (Digital Humanities Developer – University of Sheffield)
  • Keira Borrill (Research Associate – University of Sheffield)